Why I do not care about gas prices, and you should not either

As a math person, I have always wondered why people seem obsessed with gas-prices? Reviewing total cost of ownership figures for a variety of popular brands reveals that fuel (or electrons), is a fairly small overall component of total ownership costs (typically only 10-20%). Of course for EVs, particularly if you happen to have solar, distant middle east adventures matter little if at all.

We use Edmonds mostly as it is a widely research and consistent total cost of ownership calculator. One could argue endlessly if these figures are achievable or not. For example, my insurer is a slightly higher end/personal agent variety, hence I am probably paying more for car insurance than I need to. But I value the relationship, so there. But Edmonds is consistent and careful in their comparison of total cost of ownership. Do note that Edmonds reports their figures in US dollars, but we are much more interested in percentages here, so we continue. Lets check the top 5 selling cars in Canada (source), and see how they compare.

Interestingly, Canadians seem to like their rides. Three out of the top five sellers are pickup trucks, and not cheap ones either. Interestingly enough, the percentage that goes towards fuel is a relatively consistent 25%. Not a 100%, only a quarter. If we play with the numbers a bit, and say, double fuel, the total cost of ownership does not double, in fact it only goes up by 20%. Something you could easily counteract by purchasing a more fuel efficient vehicle, not to mention try going electric.

Lets compare this with a few high selling EVs (source), with some adaptations (source).

Over in EV land, things look quite different. Fuel is only 5-10% of total cost of ownership. But Depreciation is much bigger portion, about 50%, compared with about 30% for the gas guzzlers we looked at above. Insurance is also a little higher, but overall, TCO is not all that different for the EVs compared to the gas cars. Granted the revised Canadian policy on incentives, with a ramp-down in incentives, might help quell the depreciation. Also, of note, Edmonds numbers might have been compiled before the latest middle east adventure, and its resulting 150% hike in gas prices, which has a lot to do with interest in EVs.

Overall, it is well worth noting that as a percentage of total cost of ownership, fuel is likely lower than most people realise. Maintenance is another win for the EV power-train, with the exception of the Hyundai Ioniq 5, EV maintenance numbers are notably lower too.

Of course, if you took our advice and bought a gently used EV, you are on the smart end of depreciation, and might get the best deal of all.

Leave a Reply